WICSO EVALUATION RUBRIC
=========================
World Islamic Countries Organisation for Scouts and Guides
Version 2.0 - January 2025

INTRODUCTION
-------------
The Evaluation Rubric provides the criteria and rating scales used by accreditation reviewers to assess organisations against the WICSO Standards Framework. It ensures consistent and objective evaluation across all accreditation reviews.

RATING SCALE
-------------
Level 4: Exemplary - The organisation consistently exceeds the standard with evidence of innovation and best practice
Level 3: Proficient - The organisation fully meets the standard with clear evidence of effectiveness
Level 2: Developing - The organisation partially meets the standard with some evidence of progress
Level 1: Emerging - The organisation has begun to address the standard but evidence is limited
Level 0: Not Addressed - The standard has not been addressed

DOMAIN 1: GOVERNANCE AND LEADERSHIP
-------------------------------------
1.1 Governance Structure
- Level 4: Comprehensive governance framework with regular review
- Level 3: Clear structure with documented roles and responsibilities
- Level 2: Basic structure in place but gaps exist
- Level 1: Informal governance with limited documentation

1.2 Strategic Planning
- Level 4: Strategic plan with measurable goals and regular review
- Level 3: Strategic plan in place with defined objectives
- Level 2: Basic planning but not formally documented
- Level 1: No strategic planning process

DOMAIN 2: PROGRAM QUALITY
---------------------------
2.1 Program Design and Delivery
- Level 4: Innovative programs with demonstrated outcomes
- Level 3: Well-designed programs aligned with standards
- Level 2: Programs exist but limited alignment with standards
- Level 1: Programs lack structure or consistency

EVALUATION PROCESS
-------------------
Reviewers assess each standard using the rubric, gather evidence through document review, observations, and interviews, and prepare a detailed evaluation report with ratings and recommendations.